Machiavelli’s Idea of Political Order: A Metaphysical Inquiry
Author: Carl K. Y. Shaw
Abstract / Chinese PDF Download
This article examines the fundamental presuppositions and systematic articulations of Machiavelli’s political theory. I argue that Machiavelli’s thought presupposed two interrelated sets of metaphysical categories: the bipolar opposition between of form and matter, and that of ordinary and extraordinary. The contrast between form and matter represents an orientation conceiving politics as an art, which can be traced to Aristotle’s theory of the four causes. The emphasis on extraordinary, by contrast, points to the possibility of radical political change. Based on this framework, I provide a systematic interpretation of Machiavelli’s theory of political order. This article is concluded by a brief elaboration of the relevance of Machiavelli’s thought for contemporary political theory, especially civic republicanism and political decisionism. I contend that Machiavelli’s thought embraces both perspectives, consequently a theoretical synthesis is necessary.