« Taiwanese Journal of Political Science No.27Publish: 2006/03

Rethinking Political Equality

Author: Kuo-Hsien Hsu

Abstract / Chinese PDF Download

As a fundamental presumption of democracy, political equality maintains thateveryone is to be regarded and treated as political equal. But the pursuit of politicalequality,  when  driven  to  extremes,  provokes  immense  difficulty  in  improving  thequality of collective decision. Without doubt, John Stuart Mill’s advocacy of pluralvoting  testified  this  weighty  worry  in  its  traditional  form.  This  essay  tries  toscrutinize the true meaning of political equality, especially in its participation side.The essay also attempts to assert that the notion of political equality that levels offall  the  differences  and  takes  equal  influence  as  its  goal  is  not  a  desirable  one.Besides,  a  modern  and  modified  version  of  plural  voting  is  presented  to  beconsidered by democracies that face turmoil of populist origins.

Keywords:competence- plural voting thesis、equal franchise、political equality、political influence