« Taiwan Journal of Political Science No.19Publish: 2003/12

Totalitarianism and Modern Democracy

Author: Ying-wen Tsai

Abstract / Chinese PDF Download

Following Hannah Arendt’s classic work on totalitarianism, the first part of thepaper gives an account of the formation of political nihilism and redemptive utopia inthe  generation  of  the  first  world  war  and  traces  its  origin  to  the  predicament  ofpolarized tention in the development of modern liberal democracy. On the basis ofthis  account,  this  paper  tries  to  argue  that  the  novelty  of  totalitarianism  lies  in  itsattempt  at  eliminating  such  a  predicament  of  liberal  democracy  by  means  of  totalcontrol  and  terrorism  founded  upon  a  comprehensive  ideology.  With  regard  to  theinterpretation of totalitarianism, this paper proposes to revise Arendt’s thesis that theconcentration camps constitute the basic character of totalitarian regime. Concerningthis, the other parts of the paper argue that the totalitarian bureaucratic system shapedby  one  party  dictatorship  constitutes  the  political  apparatus  in  terms  of  which  thetotalitarian dictatorship totally eliminates the gap between civil society and the stateand constructs a monolithic social structure.

Keywords:bureaucracy、concentration camps、cult of leadership、ideology、liberal democracy、nihilism、redemptive utopia、totalitarianism